From the film’s IMDB.com page citation:
“In a near-future world, a lonely, physically challenged man purchases a companion robot to escape his isolation, but his own insecurities and a jealous brother threaten his chances of ever finding love.”
I’ve written many, many times on SciFiHistory.Net regarding how much I personally enjoy stories involving humans and synthetic people interacting.
Though a great many readers firmly believe I’m talking about 1984’s The Terminator – which is a very good film – that Cameron vehicle is a bit too overly invested in menacing robotics to truly tickle my fancy. Instead, I much more prefer things like the AMC and BBC co-production of Humans (2015-2018) and even its Swedish original Real Humans (2012-2014). Not to be left out, Russian television also got into the act with a bit more melodramatic and somewhat more salacious incarnation – Better Than Us (2018-2019) – that also showed what life between man, woman, and the average artificial person might look like.
Because I’ve seen so many of these series and movies, I can say with great assurance that 2025’s Personhood (aka The Perfect Lover) really isn’t breaking any significant new ground. While it’s well-written and pretty well-acted, it’s still little more than a modern day variety on the original “boy meets girl” formula. What it does insert a bit new to the recipe is it focuses on a main character – Waylen (as played by Elliot Harris) – whose lifelong spinal condition has given him a decidedly different exterior: somewhat hunched and awkwardly shaped (again, owed to the actor’s curved spine from what I’ve read), he’s a far cry from William Shakespeare’s Romeo and much closer to Victor Hugo’s Quasimodo. Most definitely, he not the usual romantic lead, and that is compelling. Mind you: both the man and this character are perfectly capable of living a full life in spite of the obstacles presented to him, but there’s no escaping the reality that some might at first glance consider him more of a work-in-progress as opposed to work-of-art.
Longing to make some kind of connection, Waylen purchases Gala (a stunning Agathe Levi), the dream woman embodiment that’s culturally been at the forefront for decades. She’s blonde, perfectly fit, knows how to fill out whatever she slips into, and programmed to fulfill whatever wish he desires. Still, Waylen – whose job appears to be remotely working in computer coding – struggles with identity issues not long after she shows up literally on his doorstep: he can’t relate to someone so perfect, and he’s at a loss to know how to communicate with something he initially views as a well-designed machine. After he inadvertently ‘damages’ her briefly when he poses too complex a psychological construct for her to compute, Waylen slowly lets his guard down and begins to develop an attachment everyone knows will grow more than physical. It does; and the two find a measure of happiness, though reality almost always has such promise fleeting.
It’s once Waylen’s abusive younger brother gets introduced into the mix – Anders (Alan Emrys) – that things begin to spiral. Initially, the younger man is attracted to Gala, so much so that he starts hinting to Waylen and her that he’d like to spend more time together. It’s innocuous at first, but that appears to be because he’s entirely unaware that Gala is a robot. (Waylen and she agreed in advance to keep her manufacture a secret.) Eventually, he stumbles onto the truth; and his fascination instead turns away from the sexual and grows even more destructively intimate … by wishing to destroy the healthy relationship those two share out of what looks to be nothing more than jealousy.
Curiously, writer/director Richard Jordan can’t quite stick the landing, and I can’t help but wonder if that was by design.
While he’s crafted an effort solid at putting all of these various plotlines into motion, his last reel grows a bit confusing, uneven, and rushed. Rather than have our script’s villain carry out a step-by-step plan to divide and conquer the lovebirds, there’s a wayward swimming pool accident that instead allows the angry young man to carry out a scheme that would both grant Gala her own measure of independence and presumably turn her away from Waylen. For no reason whatsoever given, Waylen cosmically predicts something like this is afoot; so he rushes home from his hospital bed and (a bit too conveniently) arrives just in time to see his worst fears being set into motion. Then, Jordan has the feuding brothers reconcile (in a matter of seconds?) just outside the bedroom whilst Gala’s consciousness is being refit by Anders’ hacker/friend.
When everything else regarding Lover’s story was so well conceived and tightly plotted, this laziness of a hurried confrontation and the resulting coda – we learn, indeed, that Gala becomes her own woman, apparently doesn’t ‘want’ to be with Waylen, and runs off not only with his car but also his dog (???) – is a disappointment. It smacks of invention instead of authenticity. Instead, it almost feels like the whole tale was deliberately meant to have a vague but spiritual ending, one that could then help a speaker take meaningful questions from an inquisitive audience of a film festival. A quick look at IMDB.com does show that Lover has performed favorably on the festival circuit (presently notching an impressive fourteen wins); while I personally have no issues with those events, it’s been my experience that the tastes of those who frequent such fare rarely agree with those of the ordinary viewing public.
Don’t get me wrong: because I like these kinds of films, I did enjoy a great deal of Lover. It’s a film brilliant with subtle moments, and it’s definitely well cast and handled with surprising deft by Harris, Emrys, and Levi. They make for a delicate ensemble, one of the best I’ve seen in an independent film in some time. That needs to be said.
Still, I just didn’t care for where it ultimately arrived.
The Perfect Lover (aka Personhood) was produced by Lost Dog Films. DVD distribution (for this particular release) has been coordinated by the fine folks at Vantage Films. As for the technical specifications? While I’m no trained video expert, I can still assure readers that the provided sights-and-sounds are quite good throughout: Jordan does make pretty good use of some limited staging choices with the chosen shooting locations, so there’s something to be said for keeping it all efficient. Lastly, if you’re looking for special features? Sadly, this is a bare bones release, meaning that if you want to know more then you’re going to have to look elsewhere.
Recommended.
Clearly, The Perfect Lover isn’t going to be for everyone. As a Science Fiction film, writer/director Richard Jordan really only scratches the surface of what’s possible in the relationship between man and machine, especially given the budgetary limitations. As a Noirish Thriller, it’s likely to be weighed and measured a bit lacking in its execution owed to the fact that it never quite goes far enough substantively to make a coherent whole. Lastly, as a drama, it kinda/sorta reaches a conclusion wherein the tale stops, and one can almost hear your college film professor as the lights come up, “OK, what did everyone think about this?” While I found it a noble effort – chiefly because I often enjoy minimalist SciFi – I still can’t quite answer the questions and motivations regarding two of the three principle characters, leaving me a bit underwhelmed with its nebulous closing.
In the interests of fairness, I’m pleased to disclose that the fine folks at Vantage Films (via Allied Vaughn) provided me with a complimentary Blu-ray of The Perfect Lover (aka Personhood) (2025) by request for the expressed purpose of completing this review. Their contribution to me in no way, shape, or form influenced my opinion of it.
-- EZ
RSS Feed