- Published on
(NOTE: The following review will contain spoilers necessary solely for the discussion of plot and/or characters. If you’re the type of reader who prefers a review entirely spoiler-free, then I’d encourage you to skip down to the last few paragraphs for the final assessment. If, however, you’re accepting of a few modest hints at ‘things to come,’ then read on …)
From the film’s IMDB.com page citation:
“A family's home burns under mysterious circumstances after they lose their child. Neighbors whisper of a curse as witnesses give conflicting accounts of the fire's origin, while an unsettling enigma surrounds the household.”
The joy of watching a new film is sometimes spoiled once you arrive at the story’s ultimate destination.
Sometimes, a tale simply chooses to go another direction entirely, one that was impossible to foresee, and that can make for a frustrating experience. Other times, the storyteller might employ some huge twist ending that may or may not have been predictable; and that, too, might muddy the waters enough to leave a bad impression that soils an otherwise good effort. Occasionally, writers and/or directors choose to use the tropes and trappings of a well-known genre project only to pull the rug out in the final reel, showing that what you just experienced wasn’t, say, a Horror flick after all but a cleverly presented human melodrama which conventional explanations for its unconventional packaging.
Mostly, you get the latter with Burning (2024), a nonetheless surprisingly riveting human story showcasing some absolutely incredible acting from a relatively small ensemble. Screenwriters Aizada Amangeldy and Dastan Madalbekov borrow the Rashomon-style framework to spin a complex web of relationships gone awry in more ways than one; and – depending upon one’s perspective (snicker snicker) – they may have you believing that demonic possessions are cultural exaggerations that might hide an even darker secret. While this kind of thing may have been done before, it’s still the kind of thing that works almost always when it’s tried; and thankfully director Radik Eshimov keeps things moving with a master’s focus.
Burning is the story of three people. Marat (played by Ömürbek Izrailov) and Asel’s (Aysanat Edigeeva) young marriage has been broken by the tragic loss of their young son. Distraught over developments he’s seeing in his wife, Marat chooses to have his mother Farida (Kalicha Seydalieva) come to stay with them. While the three of them are gathered together under one roof, events spiral out of control, ultimately leading to a small gas explosion that nearly destroys the home in Burning’s opening sequences.
But – and this is where the magic happens – Burning chooses to explore those dark details from the perspectives of Marat’s watchful neighbors. Jurgal (Ruslan Orozakunov) is the older next-door fellow who believes that the oppressive and dark practices of Farida forced Marat and Asel’s relationship to come apart at the seams; and his accounting of what he’s witnessed is a grand fable complete with Horror and Fantasy that’ll make the stomach churn and the blood run cold. (Seriously, Jurgal’s account is about as gruesome as I’ve seen, so those of you squeamish might need to look away here and there, especially if you’re uncomfortable with vomitting.) Second, Durus (Askar Kachkynbaev) lives across the street; and his version of events would have the kindly Marat having been seduced by the villainous Asel to the point of ruining their life and marriage. Lastly, Aisalkyn (Zhanilai Isakova) – Durus’ wife – believes that it’s only she who knows the truth of poor young Asel’s darkest secret, so she finds it incumbent upon herself to force the truth into the light of day in the finale so that justice might ultimately be served, even at the cost of reputation.
As I’ve stated above, this kind of thing has been done before. In fact, I’ve written many times that 1941’s Citizen Kane is perhaps the best example of one story unfolding through the lens of differing perspectives, but it’s the Japanese effort – 1950’s Rashomon – that scores all of the glory. Naturally, some might suggest that especially in Burning’s case we’re clearly not being given fully witnessed accounts as it grows increasingly clear that none of these versions were seen: as a result, it’s very clear – or, at least, it was to me – that Jurgal, Durus, and Aisalkyn are all interpreting the pieces of a puzzle because they weren’t in the house, in the room, or even in the vicinity to describe what takes place in each of their stories. Just as the people they describe are flawed, so are they; and this is the result of being human – namely, we fill in the gaps in order to justify our respective opinions of others.
Regardless, none of that complaint should take away from the performances here. As the matriarch, Seydalieva turns in a particularly compelling bit of work across the board: audiences are likely chilled to the bone when they see her as a domineering practitioner of the dark arts – one who might be trying to manipulate life itself – only to be equally enthralled once she’s seen as the caring, nurturing, and inquisitive elder who’s merely trying to help a young couple through their unfortunate circumstances. Equally so, Seydalieva delivers an incredible three portraits of the young Asel, two that are victims (though for differing reasons) and a third that’ll have you wishing for an exorcist to intercede immediately. Izrailov – as Marat – never quite gets the chance to shine – he’s fundamentally a bit too similar in acts one and two – though he definitely shows that he can chew scenery with the best of them in the third act. Having grown tired of males being the bad guys in everything these days, I found some of his work a bit too stereotypical; but he still emerges as a talent worthy of notice.
In the end, Burning will likely frustrate as many in the audience as it entertains. Because these three differing accounts can’t be successfully reconciled – there’s just far too much left up to the interpretation of the observer – it might be difficult to accept any of them as authentic. Still, when stories are meant to entertain, this is likely the kind of project you can’t look away from … even if you dare to keep watching …
Burning (2024) was produced by 1.1 Studio. DVD distribution (for this particular release) was provided by the fine folks at IndiePix. As for the technical specifications? While I’m no trained video expert, I can assure readers that the provided sights and sounds are quite good throughout: there was a single sequence I played twice as there was a noticeable dip in audio quality (I thought I’d missed some dialogue but it was just murky), but it’s nothing that impacts the overall experience. Lastly, if you’re looking for special features? Alas, there wasn’t a single item on the disc … and that’s always a miss in my opinion.
Recommended.
Here’s the thing: audiences showing up with the belief that they’ve about to get some incredible Horror entry are likely to be disappointed once they know fully what’s going on, and that’s a risk which sometime accompanies good storytelling, the likes of which Burning (2024) qualifies. Director Eshimov’s film teaches us maybe a bit too preachily in its finale that there are demons out there and yet perhaps they’re not as far off and/or as mystical as we might choose to believe. The plot here is simple and the premise – of experiencing one tale through differing perspectives – may not be all that original, but it works and delivers to those who’ll embrace a much more domestic packaging. This might be the first Kyrgyz film I’ve seen, but it arguably sets a very, very, very high bar for anything that could follow. Well done and relevant.
In the interests of fairness, I’m pleased to disclose that the fine folks at IndiePix provided me with a complimentary Blu-ray of Burning (2024) by request for the expressed purpose of completing this review. Their contribution to me in no way, shape, or form influenced my opinion of it.
-- EZ
From the film’s IMDB.com page citation:
“A family's home burns under mysterious circumstances after they lose their child. Neighbors whisper of a curse as witnesses give conflicting accounts of the fire's origin, while an unsettling enigma surrounds the household.”
The joy of watching a new film is sometimes spoiled once you arrive at the story’s ultimate destination.
Sometimes, a tale simply chooses to go another direction entirely, one that was impossible to foresee, and that can make for a frustrating experience. Other times, the storyteller might employ some huge twist ending that may or may not have been predictable; and that, too, might muddy the waters enough to leave a bad impression that soils an otherwise good effort. Occasionally, writers and/or directors choose to use the tropes and trappings of a well-known genre project only to pull the rug out in the final reel, showing that what you just experienced wasn’t, say, a Horror flick after all but a cleverly presented human melodrama which conventional explanations for its unconventional packaging.
Mostly, you get the latter with Burning (2024), a nonetheless surprisingly riveting human story showcasing some absolutely incredible acting from a relatively small ensemble. Screenwriters Aizada Amangeldy and Dastan Madalbekov borrow the Rashomon-style framework to spin a complex web of relationships gone awry in more ways than one; and – depending upon one’s perspective (snicker snicker) – they may have you believing that demonic possessions are cultural exaggerations that might hide an even darker secret. While this kind of thing may have been done before, it’s still the kind of thing that works almost always when it’s tried; and thankfully director Radik Eshimov keeps things moving with a master’s focus.
Burning is the story of three people. Marat (played by Ömürbek Izrailov) and Asel’s (Aysanat Edigeeva) young marriage has been broken by the tragic loss of their young son. Distraught over developments he’s seeing in his wife, Marat chooses to have his mother Farida (Kalicha Seydalieva) come to stay with them. While the three of them are gathered together under one roof, events spiral out of control, ultimately leading to a small gas explosion that nearly destroys the home in Burning’s opening sequences.
But – and this is where the magic happens – Burning chooses to explore those dark details from the perspectives of Marat’s watchful neighbors. Jurgal (Ruslan Orozakunov) is the older next-door fellow who believes that the oppressive and dark practices of Farida forced Marat and Asel’s relationship to come apart at the seams; and his accounting of what he’s witnessed is a grand fable complete with Horror and Fantasy that’ll make the stomach churn and the blood run cold. (Seriously, Jurgal’s account is about as gruesome as I’ve seen, so those of you squeamish might need to look away here and there, especially if you’re uncomfortable with vomitting.) Second, Durus (Askar Kachkynbaev) lives across the street; and his version of events would have the kindly Marat having been seduced by the villainous Asel to the point of ruining their life and marriage. Lastly, Aisalkyn (Zhanilai Isakova) – Durus’ wife – believes that it’s only she who knows the truth of poor young Asel’s darkest secret, so she finds it incumbent upon herself to force the truth into the light of day in the finale so that justice might ultimately be served, even at the cost of reputation.
As I’ve stated above, this kind of thing has been done before. In fact, I’ve written many times that 1941’s Citizen Kane is perhaps the best example of one story unfolding through the lens of differing perspectives, but it’s the Japanese effort – 1950’s Rashomon – that scores all of the glory. Naturally, some might suggest that especially in Burning’s case we’re clearly not being given fully witnessed accounts as it grows increasingly clear that none of these versions were seen: as a result, it’s very clear – or, at least, it was to me – that Jurgal, Durus, and Aisalkyn are all interpreting the pieces of a puzzle because they weren’t in the house, in the room, or even in the vicinity to describe what takes place in each of their stories. Just as the people they describe are flawed, so are they; and this is the result of being human – namely, we fill in the gaps in order to justify our respective opinions of others.
Regardless, none of that complaint should take away from the performances here. As the matriarch, Seydalieva turns in a particularly compelling bit of work across the board: audiences are likely chilled to the bone when they see her as a domineering practitioner of the dark arts – one who might be trying to manipulate life itself – only to be equally enthralled once she’s seen as the caring, nurturing, and inquisitive elder who’s merely trying to help a young couple through their unfortunate circumstances. Equally so, Seydalieva delivers an incredible three portraits of the young Asel, two that are victims (though for differing reasons) and a third that’ll have you wishing for an exorcist to intercede immediately. Izrailov – as Marat – never quite gets the chance to shine – he’s fundamentally a bit too similar in acts one and two – though he definitely shows that he can chew scenery with the best of them in the third act. Having grown tired of males being the bad guys in everything these days, I found some of his work a bit too stereotypical; but he still emerges as a talent worthy of notice.
In the end, Burning will likely frustrate as many in the audience as it entertains. Because these three differing accounts can’t be successfully reconciled – there’s just far too much left up to the interpretation of the observer – it might be difficult to accept any of them as authentic. Still, when stories are meant to entertain, this is likely the kind of project you can’t look away from … even if you dare to keep watching …
Burning (2024) was produced by 1.1 Studio. DVD distribution (for this particular release) was provided by the fine folks at IndiePix. As for the technical specifications? While I’m no trained video expert, I can assure readers that the provided sights and sounds are quite good throughout: there was a single sequence I played twice as there was a noticeable dip in audio quality (I thought I’d missed some dialogue but it was just murky), but it’s nothing that impacts the overall experience. Lastly, if you’re looking for special features? Alas, there wasn’t a single item on the disc … and that’s always a miss in my opinion.
Recommended.
Here’s the thing: audiences showing up with the belief that they’ve about to get some incredible Horror entry are likely to be disappointed once they know fully what’s going on, and that’s a risk which sometime accompanies good storytelling, the likes of which Burning (2024) qualifies. Director Eshimov’s film teaches us maybe a bit too preachily in its finale that there are demons out there and yet perhaps they’re not as far off and/or as mystical as we might choose to believe. The plot here is simple and the premise – of experiencing one tale through differing perspectives – may not be all that original, but it works and delivers to those who’ll embrace a much more domestic packaging. This might be the first Kyrgyz film I’ve seen, but it arguably sets a very, very, very high bar for anything that could follow. Well done and relevant.
In the interests of fairness, I’m pleased to disclose that the fine folks at IndiePix provided me with a complimentary Blu-ray of Burning (2024) by request for the expressed purpose of completing this review. Their contribution to me in no way, shape, or form influenced my opinion of it.
-- EZ
0 Comments